HomeMy WebLinkAbout038-1017-90-000 (2)
cRax COUN*
ro
PLANNING & ZONING
August 13, 2010 File#: LU87047
John A. Scrivener
1572 Oak Ridge Lane
Houlton, WI 54082
Code Administration` '
715-386-4680 RE: LAND USE PERMIT FOR ACCESSORY STRUCTURE, SHORELAND DISTRI' r
Land Information & LOCATION: 1160 CTY. RD. H PARCEL #03.31.18.62B, TOWN OF STAR PRAIRIE
Planning
715-386-4674
Dear Mr. Scrivener:
Real Property,
715-386-4677 This letter confirms zoning approval according to the plans you have submitted
to construct a stairway and landing attached to an existing nonconforming
Recycling principal structure in the Shoreland District of Cedar Lake in the Town of Star
715-386-4675 Prairie. Staff finds that the proposed accessory structure meets the spirit and intent
of the St. Croix County Zoning Ordinance and Shoreland District with the following
findings:
1. Single-family dwellings, accessory structures, and additions to existing
structures are allowed with a land use permit in the Shoreland District
pursuant to Section 17.35(2) (b) of the St. Croix County Zoning Ordinance;
2. The proposed stairway and landing will be attached to the principal
structure's second story on the landward side of the building. The proposed
stairway is outside the averaged setbacks from the OHWM of Cedar Lake
per Section 17.31(2) and from the road per Section 17.60.6.c;
3. No filling and grading are planned for this project;
4. The St. Croix County Highway Department has reviewed the plans and
visited the site, and taken measurements to verify that the location of the
stairway will meet the averaged setback to CTH H;
5. County staff finds that the St. Croix County Zoning Ordinance does not
specifically address nonconforming structures in the Shoreland District, but
that the proposed addition will be under 50 percent of the equalized
assessed value of the structure consistent with NR 115
Based on these findings, approval of the land use permit is subject to the
following conditions:
1. The applicants shall notify the Zoning Administrator prior to commencing
construction and when all construction is completed.
2. The applicant shall obtain all permits and approvals for this project,
including but not limited to a building permit from the Town of Star Prairie.
3. The stairway shall remain within the averaged setback to CTH H as shown
in approved site plan.
ST. CROIX COUNTY GOVERNMENT CENTER 5 386 4 686 Fax
1 101 CARMICHAEL ROAD, HUDSON, Wi 54016 71
VdWW CO.-538 R 6866 S
PZ@CD.$AI1 T-CRO1X.W1.U5
4. Within`3days of completing construction, the applicants shall su mi o e oning
Administrator photos of the completed stairway and landing. changes This approval does not allow for any additional construction, structures or structural information will
grading, filling, or clearing of vegetation beyond the limits of this request. remain on file in the St. Croix County Planning and Zoning Department. You must obtain a building
ati is your responsibility to
permit from the Town of Star Prairie prior to tomomencingl ruconstruction.
ensure compliance with any other local, state,
Please feel free to contact me with any questions or concerns.
S'
Pamela Quinn
Zoning Specialist/Zoning Administrator
Enc. Permit LU#87047
Cc: Brian Wert, Star Prairie Bldg. Inspector
Jeff Durkee, St. Croix County Hwy. Dept.
ST. CROIX COUNTY GOVERNMENT CENTER 71 rygg64686 FAX
1 101 CARMICHAEL ROAD, HUDSON, W/ 54016 7153
wWW.C 6-4686 FA
PZ@CO `~A/N7;-C'f.'QIX.WI,_L/S
o o r ca
. !„i,
M
cD 1 c c
~o,~
I c
o'
mom,
z 4000 CD ~
t^ 1--~ _
OOMWA% 0
o 0
O
_
. U)
CL W 3 1.
o CD
`D
y
(7
0 (D
got 2) 03
-Eh (D C O
Cl)
O p• Cl) ~ ~ 7C
r-IL . n Q
N
0) CD
O O o '"co :r
C
' cD -I
vi N Vi.
= = n 'D
y
looms
M p rMO.
%woo
ty s
3, . N
IMEM
MEMO
FOIL
~ Q
Ph -
°
r f
V ■
0
09
FW: Setback #1160 CTH H, John Scrivener Page 1 of 1
Pam Quinn
From: Jeff Durkee [JDurkee@scchwy.org]
Sent: Monday, August 16, 2010 7:04 AM
To: Pam Quinn
Subject: FW: Setback #1160 CTH H, John Scrivener
Pam,
The County Highway Department has no objections to the construction of the proposed deck and stairway
at 1160 CTH H. Attached are my July 28th field observations.
Jeff Durkee PE
St. Croix County Highway Engineer
From: Jeff Durkee rmailto:JDurkee@scchwy.org]
Sent: Wednesday, July 28, 2010 12:11 PM
To: pamq@co.saint-croix.wi.us
Cc: Tim Ramberg; Kevin Grabau (keving@co.saint-croix.wi.us)
Subject: Setback #1160 CTH H
Pam,
I have had a chance to look at the cabin at 1160 CTH H and feel it would be a perfect example for waiving
the setback requirement per Section 17.60.5 of the Zoning Ordinance. The proposed deck would end up
being about 42 Ft. from the centerline of H. The house immediately east of the project location (#1162) is
only 34 Ft. from the centerline with the next 3 cabins to the east ranging between 30 to 27 Ft. from the
centerline. Fire number #1158 immediately to the west has a setback of 44 Ft. from the centerline with the
next three cabins to the west ranging from 44 to 38 Ft.
Hopefully this information will help you in your decision making process, and please let me know if you
have any other questions.
Jeff Durkee PE
8/16/2010
Town of Star Prairie
Plan Commission
Minutes
August 24, 2010
Attendance: Scott C., Mike B., Jeff L., Kathy M., and Debbie R.
Absent: John H and Jeff P. Also present: Tom Heintz, Patty Schachtner, Steve
Lewis and Doug Rivard.
Meeting called to order 6:43 p.m.
Discussion of a Land Use Permit Application from John Scrivener, 1160 County
Road H, New Richmond, WI. Scrivener wishes to add a stairway/landing/fire
escape to the south side of his cabin. Motion by Kathy M and seconded by Deb
R to recommend the Town Board deny the request due to a non-compliant
setback of six foot X fourteen foot deck to County Road H, not necessary to a
minimum compliant fire escape. Motion carried.
Motion to adjourn made by Jeff L and seconded by Deb R. Motion carried
Public Hearing - Comprehensive Plan
Star Prairie Town Hall
August 24, 2010, 7 P.M.
Question and answer session. Ellen Denzer, Senior Planner for the St Croix
County Planning and Zoning Department assisted in answering questions from
the public. Members of the Plan Commission and Town Board member were
also introduced.
Public Hearing - Comprehensive Plan. Meeting was called to order at 7:40
P.M. with a motion by Jeff P. and seconded by Jeff L. Motion carried.
Public was given the opportunity to make comments on the Comprehensive Plan.
Comments were received both verbally and in written statements. The following
comments/changes were received:
Ellen Denzer, Senior Planner, St. Croix County Planning and Zoning. Presented
corrections to the Comprehensive Plan. See corrections below:
1. Typos on front cover.
2. Acknowledgements - update list of Star Prairie Town Board supervisors.
3. Town Clerk and Treasurer names updated.
4. Added "Introduction" to page 5
5. Added "agricultural enterprise area designation" on page 137 and on page
243.
6. Added a new section pertaining to the Squaw Lake Agriculture Enterprise
Area (14 pages, including a map).
Leon Orr, owns property along 220th Ave, east of County Road C and on the
west side toward the river. The property along 220th Ave., on the east side of
County Road C was subdivided. Four lots of the 80 acres were filed as a CSM
with St. Croix County and the Town of Star Prairie last fall. Orr requests that
these lots be shown as Rural Residential (yellow), just as it is across the road on
the west side of County Road C. This would prevent any future confusion as to
what those 4 lots are planned and zoned for. His second request dealt with 15
acres on the west side of County Road C, west of 127th Street. This area is part
of an earlier subdivision development worked on with St. Croix County and the
Town of Star Prairie. Unfortunately, the economy forced Orr to halt the project.
The land south of 127th Street is correctly shown as Rural Residential (yellow).
However the 15 acres on the north side of 220th, which part of the development,
is not marked correctly. He requests that this also be shown as Rural Residential
(yellow).
Allen Campeau stated that the Future Land Use Map shows his property in the
New Ag Enterprise area even though the County and the State says his property
is not in it. If the State or County does not recognize it, where does that put his
property? Campeau does not see any advantage of being in Agriculture/Forestry
if the State does not recognize his property.
Eric Wolf owns property along Brave Drive, and to the west. His property was
previously considered "Open Space", but now is has changed to Mixed
Rural/Conservation Design and the back corner of his property is considered
Open Space. Wolf requests that the Open Space portion of his land be changed
to Rural Conservation
Design.
Bruce Emerson, wishes to have his 40 acre parcel of land on 220th Street be
listed as Ag Residential or Conservation Design Residential or mixed-use. He
would like to put some lots in the 10 acres of woods. This is very low class farm
land and should not be held out for farm use only. Emerson did not request it to
be farm only and he has spoken at meetings not to have it locked-in to Ag only.
Motion to close Public Hearing was made by Jeff L. and seconded by John H.
Motion carried. 7:53 P.M.
Public Hearing - Road and Driveway Ordinance
Star Prairie Town Hall
August 24, 2010
Question and answer session preceded the Public Hearing.
Motion made by John H and seconded by Jeff L to open the Road and Driveway
Ordinance - Public Hearing. Motion carried 8:12 P.M.
No comments were received.
Motion to close Road and Driveway Ordinance - Public Hearing was made by
Mike B and seconded by Deb R. Motion carried.
Resolution to Recommend Adoption of the Town of Star Prairie 2010-2030
Comprehensive Plan. Motion by John H and seconded by Deb R to table the
Comprehensive Plan Resolution pending further review of the requested
changes made by Ellen Denzer, Leon Orr, Allen Campeau, Eric Wolf and Bruce
Emerson. Motion carried. Special Meeting of the Plan Commission to take place
on August 30, 2010, 7:00 P.M. at the Star Prairie Town Hall.
Town of Star Prairie Road and Driveway Ordinance. Motion by Kathy M and
seconded by Jeff P to recommend adoption of the Road and Driveway Ordinance
to the Town Board. Motion carried
Motion to adjourn made by John H and seconded by Jeff L. Motion carried 8:29
P.M.
Respectfully submitted,
Michael Burke
Town Clerk
Page 1 of 2
Pam Quinn
From: Alex Blackburn
Sent: Wednesday, November 03, 2010 4:13 PM
To: @Planning & Zoning Department
Subject: FW: New Richmond Pentecostals
Attachments: Pentecostals Oct 14 2010.doc; Pentecostals Nov 2, 2010.doc
See e-mail below from Scott Counter. Did anyone receive the October 14 letter from the Town of Star
Prairie? I never received it.
Alex Blackburn
St. Croix County Zoning Specialist
715-386-4680
From: Scott Counter [mailto:scott@hometecbuilders.com]
Sent: November 03, 2010 3:52 PM
To: David Fodroczi; Ellen Denzer; Alex Blackburn
Cc: Tom Heintz; spankylewis@hotmaii.com; dkrivard@frontiernet.net; townstarprairie@frontiernet.net;
Patty Schachtner; 'Peplau, Jeff - SPPC'; mjburke@frontiernet.net; 'Kathleen D. Mlynarczyk'; 'Levy, Jeff -
SPPC'; Debbie Suennen Rickard; John L Harrison
Subject: Fw: New Richmond Pentecostals
REFERENCE: PENTECOSTALS AND CEDAR LAKE DECK W/I 9' OF ROW
St Croix County Zoning Staff: V-1 e r ~4' Oft
Please note and review the following attachments from the Town of Star Prairie. It has been
disheartening how the lack of communication has now led us to two distinct decisions brought forward to
the Town of Star Prairie for action by St. Croix County Zoning for review/approval, then moved forward for
decision to the board of adjustments with no regard to the Town's position. The town has in both
instances worked in good faith to comply with the requested time lines established by the County.
It is important to work as a team in support of our common mission, to promote and protect public health,
environment, safety, and general welfare and to further maintenance of safe and healthful conditions for
the people and communities within the Town of Star Prairie, a community of St. Croix County. We must
strive to promote better communications in future requests to ensure all government entities impacted by
these decisions have been able to pay due diligence to their respective processes in an expedient
manner and proper communications and notifications have been met by all to ensure approving bodies
have had opportunity to forward their concerns before final approval of the County.
In future requests of St. Croix County to review for input/approval of variances, special exceptions,
CSM's, permitting, etcetera by the Town of Star Prairie:
1. We would request an opportunity for final communication, albeit in writing or verbal, by both the Town
and St. Croix County Zoning, to ensure our concerns are addressed and brought forward to the Board of
Adjustments for their review prior to their decision.
2. We would request you to refer the requestor of application to the Town for compliance with our review
process so as to expedite their review. Thank you.
Respectfully,
Scott Counter
11/3/2010
Page 2 of 2
715-246-4343
Home Tec Designers & Builders, Inc.
www.hometecbuilders.com
Original Message
From: Mike Burke
To: Mike Burke ; Debbie Suennen Rickard ; Jeff Lev ; Jeff Peplau ; John L Harrison ; Kathleen Mlynarczyk ;
Scott Counter ; Doug Rivard ; Patty Schachtner ; Steve Lewis ; Tom Heintz
Cc: Alex Blackburn
Sent: Tuesday, November 02, 2010 8:28 PM
Subject: New Richmond Pentecostals
The attached letters were mailed to Pastor Grant, Pentecostals of New Richmond.
Michael Burke, Clerk
Town Of Star Prairie
2118 Cook Drive
Somerset, WI 54025
715-246-9878
townstarpraide anfrontiernet.net
11/3/2010