HomeMy WebLinkAbout022-1004-30-100 (3) BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT DECISION
Request of Gary Richmond/Trout Unlimited )
for a special exception use, Article 3.4B, )
Filling and Grading(Rip rap), ST. CROIX ) A-04-86
COUNTY ZONING ORDINANCE. Location: SW14 March 25 s 1986
of the SE'k of Section 2, T28N-R19W, Town )
of Kinnickinnic. )
The St. Croix County Board of Adjustment conducted a public hearing on
March 25, 1986 to consider the request of Gary Richmond/Trout Unlimited
for a special exception use, Article 3.4 B, Filling and Grading (Rip rap),
ST. CROIX COUNTY ZONING ORDINANCE.
The St. Croix County Board of Adjustment conducted an on site inspection
of the site in question.
After inspection, the St. Croix County Board of Adjustment entered an
executive session to discuss the request.
After returning to open session, the following decision was rendered:
Motion by Supervisor Kelly to approve the rip rap. He shall have
approval from D.N.R., and Zoning Administrator is to be notified upon com-
pletion. Seconded by Supervisor Meinke. Motion carried.
Vote to approve: Kelly, yes;
Stephens, yes;
Meinke, yes.
i
All variances approved must be acted on or constructed within one (1)
year from date of approval or they shall be null and void.
7l�
Vernon Kelly, Secretary
VK:HB:mj
St. Croix County Board of Adjustment
Gary Richmond
Chuck Goossen
Town Clerk
Dan Koich, D.N.R.
Parcel #: 022-1004-30-100 01/21/2011 09:42 AM
PAGE 1 OF 1
Alt. Parcel#: 02.28.18.31A-1 022-TOWN OF KINNICKINNIC
Current )XI ST. CROIX COUNTY,WISCONSIN
Creation Date Historical Date Map# Sales Area Application# Permit# Permit Type #of Units
01/16/2007 00 0
Tax Address: Owner(s): 0=Current Owner, C=Current Co-Owner
0-KRUMM, RICHARD V&ANNE S
RICHARD V&ANNE S KRUMM
518 TROUT BROOK DR
ROBERTS WI 54023
Districts: SC = School SP= Special Property Address(es): '=Primary
Type Dist# Description `518 TROUT BROOK DR
SC 4893 SCH DIST RIVER FALLS
SP 0100 CHIP VALLEY VOTECH
Legal Description: Acres: 12.770 Plat: 5344-CSM 22-5344 022-2007
SEC 2 T28N R18W PT SW SE PT LOT 1 CSM Block/Condo Bldg: LOT 04
4-1085 NOW BEING LOT 4 CSM 22-5344
Tract(s): (Sec-Twn-Rng 401/4 1601/4)
02-28N-18W SW SE
i
i
Notes: Parcel History:
Date Doc# Vol/Page Type
12/17/2007 865796 WD
01/16/2007 842539 22/5344 CSM
10/17/1990 463288 884/08 QC
07/16/1981 372152 632/440 LC
more
2010 SUMMARY Bill#: Fair Market Value: Assessed with:
116983 287,800
Valuations: Last Changed: 09/07/2010
Description Class Acres Land Improve Total State Reason
RESIDENTIAL G1 5.000 125,000 159,000 284,000 NO 00
UNDEVELOPED G5 7.770 7,700 0 7,700 NO 00
Totals for 2010:
General Property 12.770 132,700 159,000 291,700
Woodland 0.000 0 0
Totals for 2009:
General Property 12.770 140,400 184,800 325,200
Woodland 0.000 0 0
Lottery Credit: Claim Count: 1 Certification Date: Batch#: 129
Specials:
User Special Code Category Amount
Special Assessments Special Charges Delinquent Charges
Total 0.00 0.00 0.00
BOARD OF ADJUSTMENTS MEETING AND HEARINGS
March 25, 1986
Meeting called to order by Chairman Stephens at 9:00 A.M. in the County Board
Room, Courthouse, Hudson. All members present.
Minutes of the January meeting and hearing approved.
Old Business: Air Communications of Wisconsin requested to improve the
stability of their tower in Troy Township. Motion by Supervisor Kelly to
approve the request. Seconded by Supervisor Meinke. Motion carried.
Discussion on steno-typist or court reporter at controversial hearings.
Motion by Supervisor Stephens that Finance Committee hire a steno-typist or
court reporter for Board of Adjustment hearings. This will save holding addition-
al hearings requested by the courts. Seconded by Supervisor Kelly. Motion carried.
Hearing called to order by Chairman Stephens at 9:30 A.M. Chairman Stephens
set the guidelines for the hearings. Zoning Administrator read the notice of
the hearings as published in the local newspapers:
1. ARTICLE: 2.6 A(4), Two separate houses on one lot
APPELLANT: Jeffrey A. Carlson
LOCATION: Gov't. Lots 3 & 4, Section 23,
T30N-R19W, Town of St. Joseph
2. ARTICLE: 3.12 5.12, Filling and Grading (Rip Rap)
APPELLANT: Richard Carlson
LOCATION: NEZ of the NEt4 of Section 24,
T28N-R20W, Town of Troy
3. ARTICLE: 3.4 B, Filling and Grading (Rip Rap)
APPELLANT: Roy A. Purvis
LOCATION: NWti of the NE14 of Section 26,
T30N-R19W, Town of St. Joseph
4. ARTICLE: 3.4 B, Filling and Grading (Rip Rap)
APPELLANT Gary Richmond/Trout Unlimited
LOCATION: SW14 of the SE4 of Section 2,
T28N-R19W, Town of Kinnickinnic
5. ARTICLE: 3.4 B, Filling and Grading (Rip Rap)
APPELLANT: Marie Rude/ Trout Unlimited
LOCATION: SEA of the NE4 of Section 18,
T29N-R19W, Town of Hudson
6. ARTICLE: 8.4 B (3)(b)., Setback from a County Road
APPELLANT: Kenneth 0. Hinz, Jr.
LOCATION: SW14 of the NE14 of Section 36,
T28N-R18W, Town of Kinnickinnic
7. ARTICLE: 3.12 GG, Lift
APPELLANTS: Steve and Monica Weekes
LOCATION: Lot 14, Gov't. Lot 3, Section 13,
T28N-R20W, Town of Troy
8. ARTICLE: 8.4 F(c), Driveway Separation
APPELLANT: Thomas C. Kromer
LOCATION: NW4 of the SEZ of Section 4,
T28N-R19W, Town of Troy
9. ARTICLE: 2.6 F 6, Dog Kennel and
2.6 F(13), Limited Sale of Pet Supplies
APPELLANTS: James J. and Peggy L. Thomas
LOCATION: El� of the SE14 of the SW14 of Section 24,
T30N-R19W, Town of St. Joseph
10. ARTICLE: 2.6 F(1), Duplex
APPELLANT: John F. Schmitt
LOCATION: SW14 of the NW%a of Section 30,
T30N-R19W, Town of St. Joseph
(2) r
11. ARTICLE 2.6 F(6), Dog Kennel
APPELLANTS: Don and Julia Boumeester
LOCATION: SW14 of the NWk of Section 24,
T30N-R20W, Town of St. Joseph
12. ARTICLE: 2.4 F(4), Limited Commercial Activities
(Lime Sludge Storage Facility)
APPELLANT: John T. Schottler
LOCATION: NW14 of the SW14 of Section 32,
T30N-R19W, Town of St. Joseph
Attorney Tom Bell presented the request of Jeffrey Carlson to construct a
second residence on a single parcel. Questions by board members. Chairman
Stephens read message from R. Lindholm having no objections. Mr. Ray Brown, _
Town Chairman, feels that this would set a precedent by having two house on
one lot. He objects to the request. Attorney Bell rebutted the remarks of
Mr. Brown. Mr. Brown also rebutted the remarks of Mr. Bell.
Mr. Roy Purvis presented his request to place rip rap in Bass Lake to preserve
the shoreline of his property. Zoning Administrator read letter from D.N.R.
on property.
Mr. Charles Goosen, Trout Unlimited, presented the request of Gary Richmond to
rip rap a portion of the bank on the Kinnickinnic River, Town of Kinnickinnic.
Mr. Charles Goosen, Trout Unlimited, presented the request of Mrs. Marie Rude
to rip rap a portion of the bank on the Willow River in the Town of Hudson.
Permits have not been issued by D.N.R.
Mr. Kenneth Hinz presented his request to construct a 30 X 72 foot pole shed
86 feet from a town road. The structure would be approximately 25 feet from
his drainfield.
Mrs. Monica Weekes presented their request to construct a lift on their property
located on the St. Croix River. Mr. Steve Johnson, MN-WI Boundary Area Com-
mission, has no objections to the lift. Zoning Administrator read letter from
D.N.R and Robert Ahrens, adjoining landowner, having no objections.
Mr. James Rusch presented the request of Thomas Kromer to construct a drive-
way 128 feet west of an adjoining driveway on Tower Road. Mr. Rusch stated
that the town board has no objections.
Mr. and Mrs. James Thomas presented their request to have a dog kennel and
sell limited commercial supplies on their property. Township and adjoining
landowners have no objections. Mr. John Schottler has no objections.
Mr. John Schmitt presented his request fora duplex on a parcel of land he owns
in the Town of St. Joseph. Mr. Donovan Schmitt has no objections to the request.
Mr. Ben George has no objections to the request. Town Board has no objections.
Zoning Administrator read letter from David Olson objecting to the duplex.
Mr. Gary Benaszeske objected to the duplex. Mr. John Schottler has no objec-
tions and stated there is a duplex less than a mile away. Mr. John Schmitt
stated that this would be a single family dwelling when he got married.
Mr. John Schottler presented his request for a lime sludge storage facility
on his property in the Town of St. Joseph. The storage will be from two to
five years. Michael Granger stated that the lime does not get hard and materials
are being used in Minnesota as well as Wisconsin. Town Board Chairman Brown has
no objections to the storage. Chairman Stephens read a letter from D.N.R.
Mr. Bill Anderson, Bass Lake Cheese Factory, objects to the storage and feels
that this should be held over until April when the test results should be back.
Chairman Brown stated that the sludge will not be coming over as the roads
are now posted. Mr. Donovan Schmitt wants to know the soils types in the area.
Mr. Richard Carlson did not appear before the Board of Adjustment, so his re-
quest was denied.
After inspecting the properties of those requesting hearings, the Board arrived
with the following decisions:
(3)
1. Jeffrey Carlson: Motion by Supervisor Stephens to deny; the request as
the present house poses no problem for livibility. Another house could be
built only if the present house is removed. Seconded by Supervisor Kelly.
Motion carried. Vote to deny: Kelly, yes; Stephens, yes; Meinke, yes.
2. Roy Purvis: Motion by Supervisor Meinke to approve the request for rip
rap. The rip rap can extend as far as the stumps, approximately eight feet
into the water. He shall have permits from D.N.R. Seconded by Supervisor
Kelly. Motion carried. Vote to approve: Kelly, yes; Stephens, yes; Meinke, yes.
3. Gary Richmond: Motion by Supervisor Kelly to approve the rip rap. He
shall have approval from D.N.R., and Zoning Administrator to be notified
upon completion. Seconded by Supervisor Meinke. Motion carried. Vote to
approve: Kelly, yes; Stephens, yes; Meinke, yes.
4. Marie Rude: Motion by Supervisor Kelly to approve the rip rap. Approval
from D.N.R. is required, and Zoning Administrator to be notified upon comple-
tion. Seconded by Supervisor Meinke. Motion carried. Vote to approve:
Kelly, yes; Stephens, yes; Meinke, yes.
5. Kenneth Hinz: Motion by Supervisor Kelly to grant the setback of 100-102
feet from the centerline of a town road, as a building can be adequately con-
structed in this area. Seconded by Supervisor Stephens. Motion carried.
Vote to approve as amended: Kelly, yes; Stephens, yes; Meinke, yes.
6. Steven and Monica Weekes: Motion by Supervisor Stephens to approve the
lift as it will cause less erosion than any type stairway or path. Seconded
by Supervisor Kelly. Motion carried. Vote to approve: Kelly, yes; Meinke,
yes; Stephens, yes.
7. Thomas Kromer: Motion by Supervisor Meinke to approve the 128 foot
driveway separation, with a 20 foot level approach to town road, and trees to
the east of the lot along the road be removed. Seconded by Supervisor
Kelly. Motion carried. Vote to approve as amended: Kelly, yes; Stephens,
yes; Meinke, yes.
8. James and Peggy Thomas: Motion by Supervisor Meinke to approve the request
for a dog kennel and limited sale of pet supplies, as there are no objections
and it does not cause any problems. Seconded by Supervisor Kelly. Motion
carried. Vote to approve: Kelly, yes; Stephens, yes; Meinke, yes.
9. John Schmitt: Motion by Supervisor Meinke to deny the request to construct
a duplex in the Ag-Residential District as the area now has singel family
residences. Seconded by Supervisor Stephens. Motion carried. Vote to deny:
Kelly, yes; Stephens, yes; Meinke, yes.
10. John Schottler: Motion by Supervisor Kelly to deny the request for lime
sludge storage on his property, and refer this to the District Attorney for
appropriate action for removal of lime sludge from his property. Seconded
by Supervisor Meinke. Motion carried. Vote to deny: Kelly, yes; Stephens,
yes; Meinke, yes.
11. Richard Carlson: Motion by Supervisor Stephens to deny the request of
Richard Carlson to rip rap his property on the St. Croix River as he or his
agent did not appear at the hearing. Any rip rap materials on his property
shall be removed immediately. Seconded by Supervisor Kelly. Motion carried.
Vote to deny: Kelly, yes; Stephens, yes; Meinke, yes.
The next Board of Adjustment hearings will be April 22, 1986 at 9:00 A.M.
Motion by Supervisor Kelly that Zoning Administrator inform L & G Rehbein, Inc.
that there shall be no lime sludge transported to St. Croix County until all
tests have been completed for heavy metals or hazardous materials. Seconded
by Supervisor Meinke. Motion carried.
Motion by Supervisor Kelly to adjourn. Seconded by Supervisor Meinke. Motion
carried. Hearing adjourned at 3:30 P.M.
Vernon Kelly, Secret ry
VK:HB:mj