HomeMy WebLinkAbout032-2007-30-050 (2) BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT DECISION
Request of Don Stoner for a special )
exception use, Article 8.4 B(4) (b) , )
Setback from a Town Road, ST. CROIX ) A-21-84
COUNTY ZONING ORDINANCE. Location: ) May 22, 1984
NEB of NEB of Section 2, T30N-R19W, )
Town of Somerset. )
The St. Croix County Board of Adjustment conducted a public hearing on May 22,
1984 to consider the request of Don Stoner for a special exception use, Article
8.4 B(4) (b) , Setback from a Town Road, ST. CROIX COUNTY ZONING ORDINANCE.
The St. Croix County Board of Adjustment conducted an on-site inspection of
the site in question.
. After inspection, the St. Croix County Board of Adjustment entered an Execu-
tive Session to discuss the request.
After returning to open session, the following decision was rendered.
Motion by Supervisor Meinke to approve the request as they are unable to build
a garage due to a hill on the property. The front of the garage shall be no closer
to the road than the house. Seconded by Supervisor Stephens. Motion carried.
Meinke, yes;
Stephens, yes;
Kelly, yes.
All variances approved must be acted on or constructed within one (1) year from
date of approval or they shall be null and void.
Vernon Kelly, Secretary
St. Croix County Board of Adjustment
VK:HB:mj
Don Stoner
Myrna Plourde, Town Clerk
2 -
Others speaking in favor of the request were Mary Bader, Leonard Skalicky, Margaret 5
Langness, Marty and Lee Chevalier, Lee Ballentine, Jack Sandquist and John Lowe.
Carolyn Barrette, Town Clerk, presented a map of the road and showed that the road
was established in 1877. Phillip Stringer and Robert Englehart were neutral on the
matter.
3. Mr. Thomas Gleason presented his request to construct a go cart track on his
property in 'Houlton. Anthony Huppert, track operator, explained the go carts and noise
levels. He also has a track in Prescott. A petition was presented to the Board
from adjoining land owners who are against the track. Ray Brown, Town Chairman,
informed the Board that the Town Board voted to deny the request due to traffic prob-
lems and crowd control.
4. Mr. George Sinclear presented his request to have a concession stand on the Apple
River. This is not a beer garden. Attorney James Bartholomew explained the Town
Ordinance and County Board approval of the rezoning. The Town Board has no objections.
5. Mr. Joel Springer presented his request to construct an addition to his house
that would be 125 feet from the centerline of C.T.H. "GG". His house is now 117 feet
from the centerline.. Questions by Board members. Mrs. William Smith questioned the
reason requiring a variance. Chairman Stephens explained them. Mrs. Smith has no
objections.
6. Mrs. Caroline Stoner presented their request to construct a garage that would be
120 feet from the centerline of a town road. The reason for the request is a hill
on the property. The Town Board has no objections.
7. Mrs. Harold Rohl presented their request for a limerock quarry on their property.
The quarry will be leased to Kraemer & Sons of Plain, Wisconsin. Mr. Ralph Brown
of Kraemer Construction explained that they will start quarrying limestone and crushed
rock. The lime will be available for county and private use. Mr. Gilmore Solberg,
Town Chairman, stated that the Township has no objections.
8. Mr. James Rusch presented the request of Joy Keiper to construct a house that
would be 40 feet from the bluffline of the St. Croix River District. Mr. Glen Gaynor
spoke in favor of the request. Zoning Administrator read letter from Minnesota-
Wisconsin Area Boundary Commission stating that the house could be set back 80 feet.
Questions by Board members.
9. Mr. Robert Dosedel presented his request to construct two duplexes on two one (1)
acre parcels of land. The property is•,iext to the mobile home park and the land is
not good for farm land.
10. Mr. Keven Bottineau presented his request to construct a house on his premises
that would be approximately 75 feet from the centerline of a town road and 54 feet
from Bass Lake. The all year residence will be replacing a cottage on the property.
Hearing recessed to view' all properties in question.
The Board of Adjustment. madethe following decisions:
1. Jon Erickson: Motion by Stephens to deny because it would cause water to stand
on property and back up on to adjoining land owners property. Seconded by Meinke.
Motion carried. Vote to deny: Meinke, yes; Kelly, _yes; Stephen, yes. . .
2. Joel Springer: Motion by Meinke to approve the request as the new addition
will be further from the road than the original building. Seconded by Kelly. Motion
carried. Vote to approve: Meinke, yes; Stephens, yes; Kelly, yes.
3. Don Stoner: Motion by Meinke to approve the request as they are unable to
build a garage due to a hill on the property. The front of the garage shall be no
closer to the road than the house. Seconded by Stephens. Motion carried. Vote to
approve: Meinke, yes; Stephens, yes; Kelly, yes.
4. George Sinclear: Motion by Stephens to grant approval of the concession stand
as it is a good use of the land. At completion, it shall meet with town, county and
state requirements. Seconded by Kelly. Motion carried. Vote to approve: Meinke, yes;
Stephens, yes; Kelly, yes.
5. Harold Rohl: Motion by Kelly to approve the limestone quarry and land shall be
landscaped to St. Croix County Zoning regulation at the time the quarry is closed.
Seconded by Stephens. Motion carried. Vote to approve: Meinke, yes; Kelly, yes;
Stephens, yes.
~ BOARD OF ADJUSTMENTS MEETING AND HEARING
May 22, 1984
9:00 - 4:45 p.m.
Meeting called to order by Chairman Meinke. All members present. Minutes of the
April meeting and hearing approved as written.
Election of officers: Chairman, Robert Stephens; Vice Chairman, Milton Meinke;
Secretary, Vernon Kelly.
Hearing called to order by Chairman Stephens. Zoning Administrator read notice of
hearing as published in the county and local newspapers.
1. ARTICLE: 3.4 B(1), Filling & Grading
APPELLANT: Jon A. Erickson
LOCATION: NE14 of NW-4 of Section 3,
T31N-R18W, Town of Star Prairie
2. ARTICLE: 8'.4 B(4)(b), Setback from a Town Road
APPELLANT: Joel Springer
LOCATION: SE14 of SW's of Section 1,
T30N-R18W, Town of Richmond
3. ARTICLE: 8.4 B(4) (b) , Setback from a Town Road
APPELLANT: Don Stoner
LOCATION: NE's of NEk of Section 2,
T30N-R19W, Town of Somerset
4. ARTICLE: 2.9 (18) , Concession Stand
APPELLANT: George Sinclear
LOCATION: Nli of SEA of Section 2,
T30N-R19W, Town of Somerset
5. ARTICLE: 2.6 F (7) , Limestone Quarry
APPELLANT: Harold Rohl
LOCATION: SE4 of SW4 of Section 12 & NE114 of NW'k of Section 13,
T28N-R19W, Town of Troy
6. ARTICLE: 3.4 B(1) , Filling and Grading
APPELLANT: Town of St. Joseph
LOCATION: SA of SEA of Section 26,
T30N-R19W, Town of St. Joseph
7. ARTICLE: 3.12, St. Croix Riverway District
APPELLANT: Joy M. Keiper ,
LOCATION: Gov't. Lot #2, Section 1
T29N-R20W, Town of St. Joseph
$. ARTICLE: 2.6 F(1), Duplex
APPELLANT: Robert Dosedel
LOCATION: Nlk of SEA of Section 14,
T31N-R18W, Town of Star Prairie
9. ARTICLE: 3.7 B, Setback from the Water
APPELLANT: Keven Bottineau
LOCATION: NWT of NE4 of Section 26,
T30N-R19W, Town of St. Joseph
10. ARTICLE: 2.9 A(18) , Go Cart Track
APPELLANT: Tom Gleason
LOCATION: NE14 of NW's of Section 27,
T30N-R2OW, Town of St. Joseph
1. Mr. Jon Erickson presented his request to fill and grade a lagoon on Cedar Lake,
explaining his reason for filling was due to stagnate water and odors. Questions
from board members.
2. Town of St. Joseph, filling and grading of Bass Lake on Boardman Road. Mr. Ray
Brown, Town Chairman, explained the reason for the request for filling and grading.
It is in order to make the road passable. Mr. Clifford Noreen spoke in favor.
Mr. John Schottler farms on both sides of the lake and has to travel an additional
2� miles. He will furnish the fill material from his farm.
3 -
6. Joy M. Keiper: Motion by Meinke to allow a setback of 60 feet from the bluffline
and the structure shall not exceed 25 feet from the basement floor to the peak of the
roof. This is the best usage of the land. Seconded by Kelly. Motion carried.
Vote to approve: Meinke, yes; Kelly, yes; Stephens, yes.
7. Town of St. Joseph: Motion by Meinke to approve filling and grading of Boardman
Road on Bass Lake. The project shall not start until plans have been approved from
DNR, with such plans showing a projected 5 year use of road without further construc-
tion. Seconded by Stephens. Motion carried. Vote to approve: Meinke, yes; Kelly,
yes; Stephens, yes.
8. Robert Dosedel: Motion by Stephens to approve the request to construct 2 duplexes
that will be on 1 acre lots each. They are to use the commom driveway that has been
constructed by St. Croix County Highway Department. The present usage complies with
good neighborhood usage. Seconded by Meinke. Motion carried. Vote to 'approve:
Meinke, yes; Kelly, yes, Stephens, yes.
9. Keven Bottineau: Motion by Kelly to approve the 54 foot setback from Bass Lake
as it will be further from the lake than the present structure. Seconded by Meinke.
Motion carried. Vote to approve: Meinke, yes; Kelly, yes, Stephens, yes.
10. Thomas Gleason: Motion by Stephens to deny the request due to traffice problems,
crowd, and noise levels and that it is unacceptable to village residents and township
officials as well as sanitary requirements not being met. Seconded by Meinke. Motion
carried. Vote to deny: Meinke, yes; Kelly, no; Stephens, yes.
The next scheduled Board of Adjustment Hearing is June 26, 1984.
Motion by Supervisor Meinke to adjourn. Seconded by Supervisor Stephens. Motion
carried. Meeting and hearings adjourned at 4:45 p.m.
Vernon Kelly, Secretalp
VK:HB:mj
BOARD OF ADJUSTMENT
NOTICE OF APPEAL
�- NUMBER
A. I/W E_ &4 Al of
hereby appeal to the St . Croix County Board of Adjustment from the
decision of the Zoning Administrator . Whereby the Zoning Administrator
did .
1 . Deny an application to :
Use land onlv for use as family residence
ccessory build_ n
erecsructure or building business
alter other industry
add to
other
occupy
or :
2 . Incorrectly interpret the (Ordinance) (Map) number
B . LOCATIONiUt- �EX)6- 4, Section_ v2 T N , R l_W.
Subdivision Name Lot l�
City Village Township
C . A variance of section__9Z11_- __of St . Croix County Zoning
Ordinance is requested because : (Undue hardship , unique situtation ,
etc . )
1_ 0Is// ,T-;� C®,uST��Ge ➢` �9 ��iPAG�---T A E
�DX. /,4 /!sr "�o� �'fl� �/rr�2 �.yE' d .�RAJ
R n 19 A C1110k4,1 kk eb.9�r ht� -z- Ate 0 0 -e Ilk pe-�-r Y )!e
F-a etJL`JV
I.) . List all adjoining landowners names and addresses :
.Name. Address Town State ZLp
C14-y 6 o)e D S o itJ e-)z NCU I AC C N,eV Alb �`�Q./7
Date Filed
✓'/ y - % '- -- - ------ ——---
s._
Signed Appellant (s) or Agent
i
N o
ci
0
N
O O M
N O_
N c N C
co c
O>O
,p N >c
E f0 C V
Q p N a M
U 0 j c
C y o U N
Y C
Co u> -Lim
r f6
V C N N
O N O N M O.
p p N
z c L 0
LL C p N N
cry a
o w 0
E
E d
c 'O �jNy U
0 —
EQ > f4 c N
N
M
a I
� I
o
z 4, d
N IM- Z d m
I
o z c
v o y
~ c v
m �
N f0
O
• N 0 O O OO
a m O N
O - Q w
O
N CZ � Z ozo
z
LO a+
to N
A E
►i a o CL « m
E w m 0 L
L D d m
Z N > H H H S
O o d m
0 0
•N a a a
CL
o N o o )
fn J U N N N
w`l z N o o
— O �
co O N N
M O O 7I OO 'O 7 00 O
°^' m r C
0) C>
C Q n Cn N
Cn
LO co
O RS p 0 p
° N U p N p O O N
r cn 0~_ I, o m e 0 o
v N N N
L O N c 7 C m O W
LO
0 N O � N M .yd.. N C C N O) O Ce)
•' • ~ M N O �O N O N N f6 O U
O o o to cn v o z N Y m g m
w
3
CL L, °
t A ciao 0U)
L))